PES 2015 vs FIFA 15 Player’s Ratings

PES 2015 vs FIFA 15 Player's Ratings

 

For the first time ever, Pro Evolution Soccer includes a game mode which looks like FIFA Ultimate Team: myClub. In both it is possible to build the team of our dreams using micro-transactions. Let’s compare the PES 2015 player’s ratings with the FIFA 15 player’s ratings.

 
 
 

PES 2015 vs FIFA 15 Player’s Ratings

The best players in PES don’t necessarily have to be the best ones in FIFA. The ratings in PES are slightly higher and it is funny to see that the FIFA ambassadors, like Eden Hazard, have lower ratings in PES. Here they are the FIFA 15 player’s ratings and the PES 2015 player’s ratings:

 

NAME POS CLUB LEAGUE NATION FIFA 15 PES 2015
1 Lionel Messi CF FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Argentina 93 95
2 Cristiano Ronaldo LW Real Madrid Liga BBVA Portugal 92 95
3 Arjen Robben RM FC Bayern Bundesliga Netherlands 90 91
4 Zlatan Ibrahimović ST PSG Ligue 1 Sweden 90 93
5 Manuel Neuer GK FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 90 93
6 Luis Suárez ST FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Uruguay 89 89
7 Iniesta CM FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Spain 89 89
8 Robin van Persie ST Manchester Utd Barclays PL Netherlands 88 90
9 Bastian Schweinsteiger CM FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 88 89
10 Franck Ribéry LM FC Bayern Bundesliga France 88 89
11 Eden Hazard LM Chelsea Barclays PL Belgium 88 86
12 Falcao ST Manchester Utd Barclays PL Colombia 88 88
13 Sergio Ramos CB Real Madrid Liga BBVA Spain 87 90
14 Luka Modrić CM Real Madrid Liga BBVA Croatia 87 87
15 Robert Lewandowski ST FC Bayern Bundesliga Poland 87 87
16 Philipp Lahm CDM FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 87 89
17 David Silva LM Manchester City Barclays PL Spain 87 89
18 Thiago Silva CB PSG Ligue 1 Brazil 87 89
19 Gareth Bale RM Real Madrid Liga BBVA Wales 87 90
20 Thibaut Courtois GK Chelsea Barclays PL Belgium 86 85
21 Yaya Touré CM Manchester City Barclays PL Ivory Coast 86 90
22 Wayne Rooney ST Manchester Utd Barclays PL England 86 88
23 James Rodríguez CAM Real Madrid Liga BBVA Colombia 86 85
24 Marco Reus LM Bor. Dortmund Bundesliga Germany 86 87
25 Mesut Özil CAM Arsenal Barclays PL Germany 86 84
26 Thomas Müller RM FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 86 86
27 Vincent Kompany CB Manchester City Barclays PL Belgium 86 87
28 Mats Hummels CB Bor. Dortmund Bundesliga Germany 86 85
29 Xavi CM FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Spain 86 83
30 Ángel Di María CAM Manchester Utd Barclays PL Argentina 86 87
31 Neymar LW FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Brazil 86 88
32 Edinson Cavani ST PSG Ligue 1 Uruguay 86 90
33 Sergio Agüero ST Manchester City Barclays PL Argentina 86 88
34 Hugo Lloris GK Spurs Barclays PL France 85 86
35 Petr Čech GK Chelsea Barclays PL Czech Repub… 85 85
36 Arturo Vidal CM Juventus Serie A Chile 85 87
37 Carlos Tévez ST Juventus Serie A Argentina 85 87
38 Juan Mata CAM Manchester Utd Barclays PL Spain 85 88
39 Javi Martinez CB FC Bayern Bundesliga Spain 85 84
40 Toni Kroos CM Real Madrid Liga BBVA Germany 85 86
41 Mario Götze CAM FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 85 87
42 Diego Costa ST Chelsea Barclays PL Spain 85 86
43 Sergio Busquets CDM FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Spain 85 83
44 Jérôme Boateng CB FC Bayern Bundesliga Germany 85 86
45 Karim Benzema ST Real Madrid Liga BBVA France 85 87
46 Salvatore Sirigu GK PSG Ligue 1 Italy 84 85
47 Casillas GK Real Madrid Liga BBVA Spain 84 87
48 Arda Turan LM Atlético Madrid Liga BBVA Turkey 84 83
49 Wesley Sneijder CAM Galatasaray SK Süper Lig Netherlands 84 87
50 Alexis Sánchez RW Arsenal Barclays PL Chile 84 83
51 Andrea Pirlo CM Juventus Serie A Italy 84 85
52 Piqué CB FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Spain 84 86
53 Samir Nasri LM Manchester City Barclays PL France 84 83
54 Sami Khedira CDM Real Madrid Liga BBVA Germany 84 84
55 Klaas-Jan Huntelaar ST FC Schalke 04 Bundesliga Netherlands 84 84
56 Gonzalo Higuaín ST Napoli Serie A Argentina 84 86
57 Diego Godín CB Atlético Madrid Liga BBVA Uruguay 84 87
58 Cesc Fàbregas CM Chelsea Barclays PL Spain 84 83
59 Oscar CAM Chelsea Barclays PL Brazil 84 85
60 Daniele De Rossi CDM Roma Serie A Italy 84 86
61 Giorgio Chiellini CB Juventus Serie A Italy 84 85
62 Santi Cazorla LM Arsenal Barclays PL Spain 84 82
63 Mehdi Benatia CB FC Bayern Bundesliga Morocco 84 85
64 Xabi Alonso CDM FC Bayern Bundesliga Spain 84 85
65 Roman Weidenfeller GK Bor. Dortmund Bundesliga Germany 83 82
66 Stéphane Ruffier GK Saint-Etienne Ligue 1 France 83 81
67 Diego López GK Milan Serie A Spain 83 85
68 Samir Handanovič GK Inter Serie A Slovenia 83 83
69 De Gea GK Manchester Utd Barclays PL Spain 83 84
70 Claudio Bravo GK FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Chile 83 81
71 Igor Akinfeev GK CSKA Moskva Russian Leagu… Russia 83 79
72 Hulk RW Zenit Russian Leagu… Brazil 83 85
73 Nemanja Vidić CB Inter Serie A Serbia 83 84
74 Jérémy Toulalan CDM AS Monaco Ligue 1 France 83 78
75 John Terry CB Chelsea Barclays PL England 83 81
76 Daniel Sturridge ST Liverpool Barclays PL England 83 83
77 Pedro LW FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Spain 83 82
78 Aaron Ramsey CM Arsenal Barclays PL Wales 83 84
79 Ivan Rakitić CAM FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Croatia 83 85
80 Paul Pogba CM Juventus Serie A France 83 86
81 Miralem Pjanić CM Roma Serie A Bosnia Herz… 83 83
82 Negredo ST Valencia CF Liga BBVA Spain 83 83
83 Jesús Navas RM Manchester City Barclays PL Spain 83 80
84 João Moutinho CM AS Monaco Ligue 1 Portugal 83 81
85 Per Mertesacker CB Arsenal Barclays PL Germany 83 83
86 Blaise Matuidi CDM PSG Ligue 1 France 83 86
87 Javier Mascherano CB FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Argentina 83 82
88 Claudio Marchisio CM Juventus Serie A Italy 83 83
89 Mario Mandžukić ST Atlético Madrid Liga BBVA Croatia 83 85
90 Pepe CB Real Madrid Liga BBVA Portugal 83 86
91 Marek Hamšik CAM Napoli Serie A Slovakia 83 84
92 Dani Alves RB FC Barcelona Liga BBVA Brazil 83 85
93 Ezequiel Garay CB Zenit Russian Leagu… Argentina 83 84
94 Jefferson Farfán RM FC Schalke 04 Bundesliga Peru 83 83
95 Christian Eriksen LM Spurs Barclays PL Denmark 83 82
96 Edin Džeko ST Manchester City Barclays PL Bosnia Herz… 83 84
97 Miranda CB Atlético Madrid Liga BBVA Brazil 83 85
98 Juan Cuadrado RM Fiorentina Serie A Colombia 83 83
99 Antonio Candreva RW Lazio Serie A Italy 83 83
100 Andrea Barzagli CB Juventus Serie A Italy 83 83


 
PES 2015 vs FIFA 15 Player's Ratings
 

And you ? Do you agree with these player’s ratings ? Which one seems to be more accurate to you ? PES 2015 player’s ratings or FIFA 15 players’ ratings ? Share with us your thoughts.

 
 
 
 

12 thoughts on “PES 2015 vs FIFA 15 Player’s Ratings”

  1. prefer FIFA because the rating look consisten every year compare to PES when one player being invincible then the rating in the next game increase high more than morale

  2. I am a FIFA fan and my last PES game was 2010. But looking only to the ratings, I think PES ratings are more “realistic”. FIFA overrate some players like Hazard, Falcao and James Rodriguez. I think its wrong to rate Hazard and Falcao to the same level of Ribery and Schweinsteiger.

    1. True. Messi and Ronaldo ratings are really realistic, but I think Hazard should at least be an 87 as he is playing great. One bullshit. COURTOIS????? 85???? He should be 86 or 87 with such talent. CASILLAS?!?!?!?! 87??? Such bullshit. Also Cavani and Van Persie? 90 Overall? and Zlatan should be a 91 not 93 .

  3. islikeZLATAN

    In my, opinion, we have 2 distinguished cases: in FIFA, a lot of players have their overalls boosted by the International Reputation stat( for example, Messi, the best player, is – without the IP that gives him a +3 OVR boost – actually 90, which means that- like if they weren´t enough strict with the ratings- FIFA ratings are really reaaly strict. Why have such low overalls that don’t surpass 90 when u have 1-99 rating limits? It doesn’t make sense. While this happens, in PES u have true ratings that are more suitable to the overall ranges. Still, PES is very inconsistent in relation to FIFA, because they have really different rating opinions. For example, Suarez is 89 (really 86 without IP) but in PES he is actually worth 82! But still, in my opinion, I have no preferred rating system due to the fact that they are both inconsistent and sometimes wrong.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.